ANDREW
Taylor will win because he is a better entertainer than Katherine. She has a voice, but she's not nearly as likable. Taylor has fun and its infecdtious, Katherine gets nervoiuse and over-reaches in her song choice and delivery. Sure, she has 1 good song (Somewhere Over the Rainbow), but it's not enough.
HARLEY
American Idol's platform is not "let's find the next best 'entertainer'" it is "let's find the next best SINGER." I concede that Taylor is exciting to watch, but he is nothing too special to listen to. McPhee rivals Clarkson in vocal ability - and that is not a compliment I tossd lightly around. The goal of this show is to sell records and she, my dear, will sell! sell! sell! Bottom line: America will decide... oh yes they will!
ANDREW'S REBUTTAL
It's my blog, so Taylor will win. Now get me a beer and make the bed, LADY!
HARLEY'S REBUTTAL
(censored by Andrew, so Andrew wins)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment